So You Call Yourself A Preacher?

I’m going to answer the title question with a resounding “no”—at least in the sense that I have never considered myself a “preacher” by my own choosing or qualification. God calls preachers. God sets apart preachers. God equips preachers, and God leads preachers. No man sets himself apart as a preacher, nor does a Bible college or seminary make him one.

This post isn’t meant to question anyone’s calling, but rather to express some thoughts about preaching and maybe provide some clarity about what preaching is from a biblical perspective.

According to Merriam-Webster, a preacher is “a person who delivers a sermon publicly.” But that definition is about as satisfying as severely overcooked pasta! So let me offer my own definition, which I believe is based on the history of Christianity and biblical examples:

A preacher is a man who, under the leadership of the Holy Spirit, proclaims God’s Word, accurately handling the Word of Truth by explaining (teaching) the text and applying it to the lives of those who hear.

Several words directly from Scripture should help us begin forming a solid understanding of the concept of preaching:

  • Exhort — To urge and encourage people to believe and obey God (Romans 12:1; 2 Timothy 4:2).
  • Teach — To explain Scripture so that the hearer understands what it says and how to live by it (1 Timothy 4:13).
  • Reprove — To point out error and show why correction is needed (2 Timothy 4:2).
  • Rebuke — To firmly confront sin and error (2 Timothy 4:2).

And maybe one of the most important parts that many miss: Paul ties all of these together with “great patience and teaching” (2 Timothy 4:2). Indeed, in 2 Timothy 2:24, Paul describes the Lord’s servant as one who is “able to teach.” Likewise, in 1 Timothy 3:2, the ability to teach is among the qualifications for an overseer.

But we must also recognize that while preaching and teaching are inseparable, they are not necessarily identical. Teaching seeks to explain the truth so that the hearer understands. Preaching certainly must do that, but it goes further. Preaching proclaims that truth with the authority of God’s Word and calls the hearer to RESPOND to it!

Paul beautifully brings these together in Colossians 1:28–29, where he describes proclaiming Christ, admonishing and teaching every man, with the goal of presenting every man complete in Christ. Notice that the goal isn’t simply to fill minds with biblical knowledge, but to see lives transformed by that truth!

This is why preaching must never be reduced to either a motivational speech that lacks biblical substance OR an academic lecture that leaves the hearer with a head full of information but no clear call to respond to what God has said. Faithful preaching must both INSTRUCT the mind and CONFRONT the heart with the truth of God’s Word.

Sadly, this brings us to what I believe is a key contributor to the dramatic downgrade visible in much of modern Christianity. A preacher isn’t simply someone who dictates WHAT to believe or HOW to behave. A preacher must TEACH what God’s Word says as the foundation for right belief and any genuine change in life.

I recently returned from a state association meeting, where I again heard heartfelt concerns from more than a few people, about the state of preaching in general—whether at conferences, revivals, or even the weekly gatherings of local churches. Consistently, the concerns I have heard center on the right handling of the biblical text. And it is this area that I most want to address.

First, this is not so much an attempt to define the “right” or “wrong” style or type of preaching as it is to help us understand what it means to rightly handle the text, for any genuinely biblical preaching must rightly handle the text!

For the categories that follow, I won’t necessarily stick strictly to seminary preaching-class definitions, and there will be some overlap.

Topical Preaching

Topical preaching is one of the most familiar forms of preaching today, but it is also among the most easily abused. As the term implies, topical preaching is when the one preaching selects a subject or “topic” to address, then selects biblical texts on which to base that message.

When done well, topical preaching can be both effective and God-honoring. It will be text-driven and will avoid proof-texting—plucking verses or fragments of verses out of context and making them say something they don’t actually teach.

And that is the issue I see more often than perhaps any other: the error of forcing Scripture to fit the message instead of letting Scripture shape the message. The problem really comes down to quoting a single verse or phrase in a way that ignores its original meaning.

I remember a preaching class in seminary, taught by the distinguished and respected Dr. Jesse Thomas. He opened our very first class session with a well-known verse, shared the claim most commonly preached from that verse, and asked if we had ever heard that interpretation—or had even used it ourselves.

Of course, 100% of us raised our hands!

Yet, when we examined the context, we discovered that the verse said nothing of the sort. What a way to be reminded of the importance of context!

Sadly, the practice of topical preaching can easily lead to the unfortunate habit of barely addressing Scripture, if at all.

I’ve heard agency heads and itinerant preachers speak on some moralistic or spiritual matter for an entire message, and if they read Scripture at all, the text often bears little or no connection to the speech that follows. These “sermons” are often filled with boilerplate statements about God, the gospel, and moral principles—statements that may be perfectly true and that most hearing them would heartily agree with—yet little or no scriptural foundation is offered.

But many will still enjoy and congratulate the speaker on that “message” because it was filled with familiar “truisms.”

Indeed, I am convinced that a great many errors, and even serious departures from biblical Christianity, can be traced to the mishandling of Scripture that so easily accompanies this kind of preaching.

That isn’t to say there is no place for careful, text-based topical sermons. Quite the contrary! There are appropriate times and settings for a sermon built around a particular issue that needs to be addressed. And most definitely, I would never question the work of the Holy Spirit in leading a preacher to address specific issues and events. BUT—such a message must be built on what the Word of God SAYS, not what we WANT it to say!

The command from Paul in 2 Timothy 4:2 again rings out:

“Preach the word…”

Not opinions or agendas forced onto the Word!

But this brings us to the other end of the spectrum:

Expository Preaching

Expository preaching is preaching that explains a Bible passage in its context and shows how to apply its meaning to everyday life.

The main point of the passage becomes the main point of the sermon.

Most people understand expository preaching to be distinguished by its “verse-by-verse” format. BUT just because a preacher goes verse by verse does not mean he is truly preaching expositionally.

The fundamental characteristic of expository preaching isn’t the number of verses covered or the order in which they’re addressed. It is that the meaning and purpose of the passage govern the message and its application.

I sometimes see churches pointing to their “line-by-line” preaching, which might be good, but that alone isn’t evidence of expository preaching.

Some who have had a steady diet of topical preaching find themselves uncomfortable with expository preaching. Maybe that discomfort comes from its sometimes more academic feel. Or perhaps it comes from discovering that something they have long heard about a biblical text wasn’t actually what the passage meant when understood in its proper context. But there are some very real advantages to a focus on expository preaching. Among the most important:

  • Context: The most important key to understanding any text, whether the Bible or other writings, is context. I’ve often heard, “Context is king!” My own mother, a college English professor, used to say, “A text without context is nothing but a pretext.” In short, without context, it is treacherously easy to force meaning onto a text.
  • Consistency: Expository preaching helps produce consistency by making Scripture, rather than the preacher’s opinions or agenda, the fundamental guide for each sermon.

And that consistency brings several additional benefits:

  • Message: Since the passage determines what is taught, it helps the preacher remain faithful to the actual meaning of the text.
  • Method: Each sermon follows a dependable approach—read the passage, explain its meaning, and apply it to life.
  • Balance: When preaching through a book of the Bible, the preacher addresses both familiar and difficult texts and subjects instead of sticking with comfortable, familiar topics.
  • Continuity: Moving through passages in order helps listeners follow the biblical writer’s train of thought while helping the preacher plan ahead.

All of these contribute to far greater consistency in the faithful handling and preparation of the text.

What About Series?

There has been a visible growth in the preaching of sermon series. Some are simply themed expository walks through books of the Bible, while others are far more topical in nature, all centered on a particular theme.

I am finishing up a short series in Psalms that has focused on the theme “From Heartache to Joy.”

Each message has been a fundamentally expository handling of a Psalm, each addressing a different aspect of the heartache and grief we experience in life, and how God brings comfort, hope, and joy in the midst of those struggles. I began with a topic, but used an expositional approach in selecting the texts and in teaching and applying them.

We recently held revival services at Soda Baptist Church with my friend Bro. Wade Lentz (Beryl Baptist Church, Vilonia, Arkansas) as our guest evangelist.

I believe many were somewhat shocked that the entire series of revival services was an expository walk through the Old Testament book of Haggai. In five messages, he unpacked and applied the entire book! (OK, it’s only two chapters.) I’m pretty certain that few, if any, of those who attended all or part of the revival services had ever heard such an expository walk through a book of Scripture as a revival series.

Yet, by making it a series through the book, Bro. Wade was able to weave together a cohesive message that was memorable, consistent, and incredibly applicable to the church today. (LISTEN TO THE SERIES HERE)

We have to be careful, though, not to allow a series and its theme to become what drives the message.

The TEXT should always drive the message!

Preaching in a defined series helps listeners “connect the dots,” building greater understanding and making the overarching theme more memorable and impactful.

It can also help drive home the bigger picture of Scripture as a consistent narrative of God’s redemptive plan and work.

On the other hand, the idea of “sermon series” has also been abused.

I’ve seen sermon series built around Hollywood movies and popular video games. While such themes may be designed to attract people, they can become so topic-driven that the Bible is hardly even mentioned. When Scripture becomes little more than an accessory to the theme, the result is often a moralistic, therapeutic message rather than the faithful proclamation of God’s Word. This kind of preaching truly misses the mark and completely forgets that command to “Preach the word…”

The Work of the Holy Spirit in Preaching

There is another common misunderstanding about preaching that has created biases on both sides of the preaching spectrum: the role of the Holy Spirit in preaching.

Those most comfortable hearing topical preaching sometimes feel that preaching in a series, especially full-blown expository preaching through books of the Bible, can’t possibly be Holy Spirit-led. I have even heard it said that “a preacher should just give us the Bible and trust the Holy Spirit to guide his words.”

A printed devotional page titled “From Heartache to Joy,” reflecting on Psalm 30 and finding hope in God.

While I don’t necessarily disagree with the sentiment of depending on the Holy Spirit, what is often meant by that statement is that preachers shouldn’t spend too much time writing their sermons or relying on notes and manuscripts they’ve prepared. It almost becomes a call for mystical, extemporaneous preaching, where the only formal preparation is prayer and trusting the Holy Spirit to provide the words.

But from the expository end of the spectrum, we can become somewhat prideful and overly confident in our scholarly or academic abilities, sliding into biblical teaching that misses the practical application of the text.

If our preaching becomes little more than filling minds with biblical facts, we have accomplished little and missed a central purpose of preaching altogether: to call the hearer to respond to the truth of God’s Word. Whether that means repentance from sin and error, reconciliation with God and other people, growth in faithfulness and maturity, or a call to action, every text of Scripture has a purpose that God intended it to accomplish. The fact is, God is God, and He can (and does) lead preachers to preach both topical and expositional messages.

What He does NOT lead preachers to do is force meaning onto Scripture or abuse a biblical text as a means of promoting their personal opinions.

Surely we would never suggest that a preacher should abandon prayer and dependence on the Holy Spirit in favor of academic preparation. But why would we suggest that the Holy Spirit cannot work through hours of prayerful study, careful examination of the text, and diligent preparation? Is the Spirit somehow less involved in guiding a man through the Word during the week than He is when that same man stands in the pulpit on Sunday?

Lest we forget, the apostles devoted themselves to prayer and the ministry of the Word. Paul commands diligence in accurately handling Scripture. Yet Paul also emphasizes that his preaching depended upon the Spirit’s power. These truths are complementary, not contradictory. (Acts 6:4; 2 Timothy 2:15; 1 Corinthians 2:4-5)

The preacher must depend on the Holy Spirit, both in the study and preparation of the message and in its proclamation and application.

A Last Thought

My daughter chose farrier work (horseshoeing) as a vocation. She attended a nationally known school to receive the training and education necessary to properly handle the trimming, shoeing, and health of horses’ hooves.

While some might think it would be as simple as learning how to file a hoof and nail on a properly sized shoe, approaching the work that way would be malpractice! Not only did she have to study physiology and equine kinesiology, but even though she generally uses commercially made horseshoes, her training began in the forge, pounding out shoes from bars of iron. She had to learn not only how to shape the metal, but also the mechanics of horseshoeing, before ever placing a shoe on a horse.

The philosophy of the school was that students should understand how to properly handle both the hoof and the metal before taking on the rest of the job.

Likewise, preachers should first learn how to rightly handle the Word of God, and I am convinced the best way to develop that ability is to begin with expository preaching. Learn how to rightly handle any and all biblical texts within their context, find the main idea of the passage, and build the message from that. Learn how to faithfully handle Scripture before venturing into preaching on particular subjects or topics. Because even a topical sermon should be text-driven, not agenda-driven.

And don’t automatically assume that a sermon that is topical or expositional (especially as part of a series) isn’t given by the Holy Spirit to the man who delivers it. The real question isn’t whether a sermon is topical or expositional, whether it is part of a series or a stand-alone message, or even whether the preacher uses a manuscript or preaches from brief notes, the question is whether the preacher has faithfully proclaimed what GOD has said, rather than what the preacher wanted to say.  A preacher’s calling is not to find a verse that supports his message. His calling is to find the message God has already given in His Word, then faithfully proclaim it.

And that, I believe, is what it means to truly “Preach the Word.“

Leave a Reply